Saturday, January 21, 2012

Taylor Hicks and Country Soul--Looking for genre...

“Country and blues, they aren’t just cousins; they’re blood brothers.” –Ray Charles

Taylor Hicks releases new music in 2012. He has called it “country soul”—that mix of two great genres.

I went looking for the genre…the honesty of country, the intensity of soul and closely related, blues.

I found both the expected and unexpected.

Historically, “‘Country Soul’ resulted from the shared genealogy of gospel in both soul and country music;” when white gospel and black gospel styles, first with major stylistic differences, somewhat merged in the 1950s. “…country-soul was in actuality the triumph of country gospel traditions seeping into soul music.

“Although artists like Albert Alexander and Solomon Burke had already begun tentatively exploring this style by 1960, Ray Charles' landmark 1962 album Modern Sounds In Country And Western is often considered the commercial breakthrough of the genre. The style lasted well into the early Seventies, with several spinoff genres like the more gospel-heavy and emotional "Deep Soul," the grittier, bluesier "Southern Soul," and the later, funkier variant known as "Swamp Rock."
(Oldies/about.com)

So all of these variants might also play a part in the “country soul” of Taylor Hicks, particularly, and I am guessing here, the bluesier “southern soul” and funkier “swamp rock.”

The randb.about.com site cites R&B as an ancestor of the mixed genre:

“Although they seem like distant relatives now, R&B and Country & Western used to be close cousins back in the day. In the 1960s and '70s many R&B artists, particularly ones from the South, used to remake Country songs and inject them with a healthy dose of R&B. There's even a name for the mixed genre: Country-Soul.” (randb.about.com)


Randb.about.com also defines country soul with a list of who it is—a primarily country singer dueting with a primarily soul or blues singer:

“Rhythm, Country And Blues, Various Artists”
This is a collection of duets between Country, R&B and Blues artists. "Funny How Time Slips Away"( Aaron Neville/Trisha Yearwood) and "I Fall To Pieces" (Al Green, Lyle Lovett) won Grammys in 1995.

1. Ain't Nothing Like the Real Thing: Vince Gill/Gladys Knight
2. Funny How Time Slips Away: Al Green/Lyle Lovett
3. I Fall to Pieces: Aaron Neville/Trisha Yearwood
4. Somethin' Else: Little Richard/Tanya Tucker
5. When Something Is Wrong With My Baby: Patti LaBelle/Travis Tritt
6. Rainy Night in Georgia: Sam Moore/Conway Twitty
7. Chain of Fools: Clint Black/The Pointer Sisters
8. Since I Fell For You: Natalie Cole/Reba McEntire
9. Southern Nights: Chet Atkins/Allen Toussaint
10 The Weight: Marty Stuart/The Staple Singers
11 Patches: George Jones/BB King

It was an aha moment as I read the list. I didn’t think I was a country-soul fan, but these were some of my all-time favorite songs: “I Fall to Pieces,” “Rainy Night in Georgia” (and another favorite Georgia song: “Midnight Train to Georgia” is also on some country-soul lists) “Southern Nights” and “The Weight” (“…take a load off”) .

Some of these have also been on the setlist for Taylor Hicks concerts, probably most frequently, “The Weight” with Rick Carter.

From Rateyourmusic.com genre of country+soul:

“Country soul has its roots in Gospel, Rhythm & Blues, and Country music, while musically emphasizing the signatures and textures of country music over the grittier and horn-driven sound of Southern Soul.”

Its list of a few musicians representing Southern Soul:
Otis Redding
Aretha Franklin
Sam Cooke
Al Greene
Etta James
Bobbie Gentry

But everywhere one recording and one artist topped the country-soul list: Ray Charles’ “Modern Sounds in Country and Western” with the amazing sounds of the Genius of Soul.

From “Ray Charles-Modern Sounds in Country and Western” on YouTube: JazzVideoGuy: “ ‘Modern Sounds’ and its lead single, ‘I Can't Stop Loving You,’ were both certified gold by the Recording Industry Association of America in 1962…

“Regarded by many critics as Charles's best studio album, Modern Sounds in Country and Western Music has been considered by several music writers to be a landmark album in American music. The album's integration of soul and country music bent racial barriers in popular music, amid the height of the African-American civil rights struggle. In the process of recording the album, Charles became one of the first African-American musicians to exercise complete artistic control over his own recording career. In 2003, the album was ranked number 104 on Rolling Stone magazine's list of the 500 greatest albums of all time.”

“I Can’t Stop Loving You” uploaded by Hkiramijyan:






"'I Can't Stop Loving You' is a popular song written and composed by country singer, songwriter and musician Don Gibson, who first recorded it on December 30, 1957, for RCA Victor Records. It was released in 1958 as the B-side of Oh, Lonesome Me, becoming a double-sided country hit single.

“The song was also recorded by Ray Charles in 1962 and released from Charles' groundbreaking Modern Sounds in Country and Western Music album. The Ray Charles cover version reached number one on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1962, as well as the U.S. R&B and Adult Contemporary charts and ranked #161 on Rolling Stone's list of the 500 Greatest Songs of All Time and #49 on CMT's 100 Greatest Songs in Country Music.” (YouTube upload by Hkiramijyan)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r_7iRVtxui8&feature=related

That was then. This is now:

I found an updated version of country-soul with whom I thought was an unusual artist—the top selling singer in 2011, Adele. With her gospel soul,“Rolling in the Deep,” a top selling single of 2011, tucked away on the b-side, “If It Hadn’t Been for Love,” is a musically lighter track called a “country-soul gem” by covermesongs.com.

Music blogger, Bob Lefsetz, in a glowing review of Adele at The Greek where he describes her as “honest” and with what many other artists are missing—a personality, calls this tune a “surprise” and “genre-hopping.” “The surprise was ‘If It Hadn't Been For Love,’ the cover that is tacked on to "21"[album] as a bonus track. The genre-hopping was mindbending.”

With her unsual honesty, the British pop sensation in her iTunes concert introduced it: “This song is about shooting your wife!”

“Never would have hitchhiked to Birmingham
If it hadn’t been for love.
Never would have caught the train to Louisian’
If It hadn’t been for love.”

“If It Hadn’t Been for Love:”






“Traditional” country soul and a modern day example of a musically lighter, if not lighter themed “country soul gem.”

Then I lost my trail on genre...

Ray Charles has never been one of my favorite singers. In viewing videos and researching for this piece, I watched several. Then I happened upon this stunning video of Brother Ray later in his career singing “A Song For You.” I fell in love with the song again and with this artist whose music connected with haunting intensity…haunting, because I cannot tell you why it touched me…why I suddenly loved Ray Charles singing this song. It was as if is was MY song! That is the beauty and essence of music….genres be damned!

It didn’t matter at all to me into which pigeonhole—genre--this song might fall.

My search became a contrast between what we may know about genres and what we feel about the song.

It all comes down to the music.

Van Morrison was asked in 1981 if he thought about his audience at all when he was writing. He said:

“Not really, because you can't think about anything when you're writing except that. It's like if you're a carpenter, you can't build a shelf well if you're thinking about who you're going to sell it to. You have to build the shelf first, and then whoever wants to buy it...” (VanMorrisonNews.com)

And another aha moment: I hope Taylor Hicks isn’t thinking about genres…or me. I hope he is thinking about the music he LIKES. The music that is him. When he performs it, it speaks for him, whatever the genre.

It was reported that Ray Charles liked Country and Western Music and that’s why he recorded Modern Sounds.

So, I hope Taylor Hicks is thinking about what he likes, who he is--not what he thinks someone else wants to hear.

We all put ourselves “out there” every day and people respond or they don’t. Music too. He puts HIS music out there—what is HIM and people respond or they don’t, but he remains true to who he is.

That’s what I hope “country-soul” means to Taylor Hicks!

It’s not about genre, folks!!!


Ray Charles proved that to me. Perhaps “genre” means something in the business…where it plays or is listed…

But, I don’t buy a genre. I buy the song, the artist. If it speaks to me, connects with me, I’ll find it…whatever the genre!

~~~

“I love you in a place where's there no space or time.”
Ray Charles: “A Song for You”

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g-fIroypwsI&feature=fvwrel







~~~
P. S.
If country soul can be one country singer and one soul singer, there is no better country-soul duet than Willie Nelson and Ray Charles with “Seven Spanish Angels:”

Uploaded By Arnescountry on YouTube:






Just Because

~~~
P. S. S. “I Can’t Stop Loving You,” is on the setlist of Van Morrison’s current live tour in Great Britian!

~~~
Sources:
http://oldies.about.com/od/soulmotown/g/countrysoul.htm

http://randb.about.com/od/top5lists/tp/CountryRemakes.htm

http://rateyourmusic.com/genre/Country+Soul/

Ray Charles quote and “Ray Charles-Modern Sounds in Country and Western Music," the landmark 1962 recording by Ray Charles, is featured in this edition of the podcast series, "Ray Charles, Genius," produced by Bret Primack for Concord Records uploaded by jazzvideoguy on YouTube. This is a great podcast:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uFwezLSuT4I

“I Can’t Stop Loving You” YouTube
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r_7iRVtxui8&feature=related

“Adele Unearths Country-Soul Gem”
http://www.covermesongs.com/2011/01/adele-unearths-country-soul-gem.html

Van Morrison quote:
http://vanmorrisonnews.blogspot.com/search?updated-max=2011-11-04T09:06:00Z&max-results=10

~~~~

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

I hate when musicians get pigeon-holed into a genre specified by the PTB.
If the song is appealing and the voice is appealing , I don't care what the classification of a song /singer is.

Sad that "lousy " singers /performers get big promotions and sales because of past history rather then quality music.

Taylor Hicks has the ability to adapt to any "genre" with vocal agility.

cath

san said...

I learned rather quickly that the genre didn't matter! He certainly can do genre hopping! Thanks for reading and commenting, Cath.

KarinP said...

Enjoyed your blog. Genre means nothing to me either unfortunately, it does seem to matter to the radio stations and the music awards.

It seems to me that "Country" whether it be twangy country or Country Soul is the place to be these days. A friend told me about a song called "Out of Goodbyes" by Maroon 5 (Pop/Rock) and Lady Antebellum (Country). This song has a "country feel" to it. I listened to it and I really like it.

What matters to me is the artist; his/her voice; the way the artist tells me the story; and the melody/music.

Don't you just love the songs that really "hit home" with you? When a song touches my soul and my heart, it doesn't matter what genre it is. I think a lot of the time it depends on "where we are".

Taylor was criticized in the beginning, if I am recalling correctly, because he couldn't be slotted into a genre. Now, it seems to me that everyone is hopping fences but the place to be is on the Country charts. There is something different about Country Artists. They tell a story; they "feel" the story; you can actually decipher the lyrics and I can't think of a better place for Taylor's music to be. He has a unique way of telling his story.

I have always hoped that Taylor would release "Maybe You Should" because I really think that song is one that many listeners can relate to. Lately, I have been listening to Taylor's AI performances - Just Once and Something - love them both.

He has been under-rated and we will never know why but I still enjoy his music. I am looking forward to his new CD and no doubt, I will probably have more than one favourite song on the new album.

I remain hopeful that his voice will be heard the way that many of us have heard it from Day 1. Bottom line - if an artist stays true to himself, they are keeping the music "real" for them which benefits everyone. Just "Keep It Real."

san said...

Thanks, Karin, for reading and for your thoughtful comments. I'm glad you enjoyed it. I enjoyed finding more about "country soul" and especially finding a Ray Charles that I could love! I think it was the "imperfections" that grabbed me...imperfect, like me; like you! Our imperfections make us real. Life is imperfect!

Thanks again for commenting!

Anonymous said...

Just a great well thought out blog, with an amazing list of great music. Long time ago I got into an argument with someone on an old blog about country and soul and blues. They were convinced there was no relationship of any kind. I was somewhat dumbfounded by that opinion. So many it seems seem to think country means old twangy artists. That is just a little part of it and when someone like Ray Charles or Solomon Burke took a country song and made it into something very special I saw it was just different ways of interpreting the same song. I know someone in radio told me that you just have to settle on a genre to get played on radio. That is so sad if true. If someone has the ability to do many genres why should they have to limit themselves. Just isn't right. I don't know, maybe Taylor will always be quality instead of quantity but somehow I think he will work it out. I know he gets a lot of respect in a good part of the music world and that will help.
Thanks for a great blog and all the music and great quotes.
ParleyBlueHenry on twitter

san said...

Thanks so much for your comments, ParlyBlueHenry. Country has certainly changed since my Dad faithfully watched The Grand Ole Opry! I have read over and over that an indie artist like Taylor has no chance of being played on radio without the contract with the big guys. So sad! I've also read that radio is not the place to be..it is now an internet world where the fans are tops! I hope so because we will be here for Taylor!

Thanks again for taking the time to read and comment!

I appreciate all the comments here!!!

medolark said...

These same thoughts have been on my mind lately. I'm staying in AZ & my son's stations are always on country. I have been surprised at how many of the songs don't sound any different to me than the songs Taylor sings like MYS: ie: Lady Antebellum, Just A Kiss. I saw Reba on TV and she was asked about a pop song she recently recorded and she said she didn't think there should be genrés; just great songs. I totally agree.

Thanks, San for this well researched blog. I enjoyed reading it & the vids were icing on the cake. Ü

san said...

You are very welcome, Medolark, and welcome back to Arizona! There is definitely a lot of country music here. And I agree with you and Reba, there are just great songs! Almost every genre has some great songs.

I really enjoyed the research for this. I learned much myself. And I found my reason to love Ray Charles the way so many do!

Thanks very much for reading and commenting! I appreciate your thoughts.